401k, IRA, Roth, Roth Conversion, Backdoor
January 24, 2021

Myths of Roth/IRA

1. Nonworking spouse cannot contribute to IRA/Roth.

  • A married couple having earned income and filling tax-return as marred filing jointly may open IRA/Roth for both spouses.

2. Only W-2 jobs permit IRA/Roth contributions.

  • Any earning income from a business, side, or contractor job (on 1099) makes you eligible to open and contribute to IRA/Roth.

3. Kids are not eligible to open IRA/Roth.

  • Kids having official earned income are eligible to contribute to Custodial IRA/Roth.

4. IRA may hold only pre-tax contributions.

  • IRA may contain both pre-tax and after-tax money.
  • Earnings in IRA are always pre-tax.
  • For accounting contributions as "after-tax", Form 8606 must be filed.

5. Employer-sponsored plans, like 401k, disqualify from contributing to IRA.

  • If you have earned income, contributions to IRA are allowed (up to certain annual limits).
  • IRS limits high-income earners (if one of the spouses is covered by employer-sponsored retirement plans) on receiving tax deductions for IRA contributions.

6. High-income earners cannot contribute to Roth IRA.

  • There are limits on high income (MAGI) for direct contributions to Roth IRA, but Backdoor Conversion to Roth IRA may work for any income level.
  • Pre-tax contributions to employer-sponsored retirement plans reduce MAGI, which may make you eligible to contribute to Roth.

7. The deadline for contributing to IRA/Roth is the end of the calendar year.

  • The deadline for contributions to IRA/Roth is 15 April (extensions are not allowed).
  • Pre-tax contributions to IRA must be reported on tax-return to receive tax deductions.
  • After-tax contributions to IRA must be reported on Form 8606.

8. Penalty-free withdrawals of the direct contributions from Roth IRA are allowed only after the 5-years period is over.

  • The direct contributions to Roth could be withdrawn at any time penalty-free.
  • Roth Conversion (including Backdoor) could be withdrawn penalty-free after 5-year is over from the conversion year.

9. One should estimate with an accountant the tax implication accurately before deciding whether to go with IRA or Roth IRA.

  • Contributions to Roth/IRA might be canceled before April 15 (tax-period deadline).
  • Before April 15, IRA contributions could be recharacterized (from traditional to Roth or vice versa).

10. IRA/Roth allows investing in the stock market only.

  • IRS allows using SDIRA (Self Directed IRA/Roth) for investing in alternative assets, like real-estate, business, crypto, and more.

11. The limit on Roth contributions is $6,000 annually.

  • 50+ years old individuals may contribute to IRA/Roth up to $7,000 a year, subject to certain constraints.
  • If eligible, one may max out other similar plans, like SEP, solo-401k, 401k.
  • Roth Conversion and (Mega) Backdoor may allow maxing out Roth-contributions up to very high limits.

12. Early distributions from IRA are always penalized.

  • There are several exceptions, like paying for education, substantial medical expenses, up to $10,000 for the first home purchasing.
  • 72(t) rule allows penalty-free early withdrawals.
  • Five years after a Roth Conversion (or after reaching the age of 59.5 years old), the converted amount could be withdrawn penalty-free.

13. IRA/Roth could always be rolled over to 401k

  • IRA could be rolled over to 401k if the plan allows Reverse Rollovers and if IRA does not contain after-tax money.
  • Roth cannot be rolled over to Roth 401k.

14. IRA Rollovers and Roth Conversions count toward an annual IRA/Roth contribution.

  • Rollovers/conversions from qualified retirement plans (401k, 403b, IRA) to IRA/Roth do not count against annual contribution limits.
  • Rollovers and conversions do not have any income constraints or limitations on the rolled over/converted amount.
  • Roth Conversion is a taxable event, so the converted amount must be included in your taxable income.